Nance's Mustard Manufacturer
Nance’s Mustard brings a punch of Rochester-born flavor that instantly wakes up any dish. Sharp, creamy, and unmistakably zesty, it’s the regional classic that found its way onto shelves across more than 25 states without losing its hometown soul. Each jar carries the smooth, bright character fans crave—crafted in Macedon, NY by Baldwin Richardson Foods and beloved by anyone who thinks condiments should do more than sit quietly on the plate.
Top Nance's Mustard
Nance’s Mustard Sharp & Creamy
The brand’s flagship mustard, celebrated for its bold, smooth flavor with a subtle sweetness and lingering horseradish-like heat.
Nance’s Mustard Original Hot
A spicier twist on the classic, offering extra heat while retaining the signature creamy texture and mustard punch that fans love.
Nance’s Honey Mustard
A sweeter, more mellow variation that blends mustard tang with gentle honey notes for those who prefer a milder, balanced condiment.
A burst of bold, creamy heat defines every jar—Nance’s Mustard turns simple meals into flavor-packed moments.
Product Categories
Sharp & Creamy Mustard
This signature variety delivers a strong mustard bite balanced with a touch of sweetness and a lingering horseradish-like warmth, crafted from all-natural, high-quality ingredients.
Hot Mustard
A kicked-up version of their classic flavor, offering deeper heat while keeping that smooth, zesty profile fans love.
Specialty Mustards & Condiment Variants
Additional mustard styles and related condiments extend the brand’s tradition of bold, kitchen-ready flavor, perfect for dipping, spreading, or cooking.
Reviews
Emily Carter
I grew up on bold mustards, but Nance’s Sharp & Creamy completely redefined what I thought mustard could be. The first taste hit me with that strong, clean mustard pop, then melted into a smooth sweetness before finishing with a warm, horseradish-like kick that lingered in the best way. I’ve used it on pretzels, mixed it into dressings, and even whisked it into meatloaf—every time, it transforms the dish. It’s now the jar I reach for without even thinking.
Daniel Rodriguez
My family hosted a backyard cookout last month, and someone brought a jar of Nance’s Hot Mustard. I slathered it on a grilled sausage expecting a basic condiment, but wow—this had depth. The heat was assertive but clean, never overwhelming, and the texture was unbelievably smooth. Guests kept asking where it came from, and by the end of the night the jar was scraped empty. It’s officially a staple in our pantry.
Sophie Bennett
I love experimenting in the kitchen, and Nance’s specialty variations have become my secret weapon. I mixed the sharp & creamy variety into a honey-mustard glaze for roasted veggies, and the flavor absolutely bloomed in the oven—bright, tangy, and just spicy enough to sparkle. It tastes genuinely natural, without that artificial tang some mustards have. Every jar feels crafted with care, and it shows in every recipe.
Nance's FAQ
What is Nance’s Mustard made of?
Nance’s Mustard is crafted with all-natural ingredients, including water, mustard flour, vinegar, sugar, and select spices, delivering a bold, smooth flavor without artificial additives.
Is Nance’s Mustard gluten-free?
Yes, the Sharp & Creamy variety is gluten-free, making it suitable for those with gluten sensitivities while still offering a full, zesty taste.
How spicy is the Sharp & Creamy mustard?
It has a noticeable mustard heat with a slightly sweet undertone and a lingering horseradish-like kick—spicy enough to excite the palate without overwhelming it.
Where can I buy Nance’s Mustard?
Nance’s Mustard is available in over 25 states through grocery stores, online marketplaces, and specialty retailers; some sites offer multi-pack deals with free shipping.
Can I use Nance’s Mustard for cooking?
Absolutely—its smooth texture and bold flavor make it ideal for marinades, sauces, dressings, dips, and even recipes like meatloaf or roasted vegetables.
How should I store Nance’s Mustard?
Store unopened jars in a cool, dry place. Once opened, refrigerate to maintain freshness and flavor for an extended period.
Does Nance’s offer other condiment varieties besides mustard?
Yes, the brand also produces Honey Mustard, Original Hot Mustard, Chili Sauce, Chicken Wing Sauce (Hot and Mild), and Corn Relish, all crafted with the same commitment to bold flavor.